---
language: en
canonical: https://bessonov.com.ua/en/knowledge/temporary-seizure-vs-arrest-of-phone
---

# Temporary seizure or court-ordered restraint of a phone in Ukraine

[Back to knowledge base](https://bessonov.com.ua/en/knowledge)

Urgent Property 13 min

Short answer

Temporary seizure is the physical taking of a phone pending a decision on court-ordered restraint or return. A restraint order is a separate judicial restriction on using, disposing of or transferring property. Following a warrant-based search, a petition concerning a temporarily seized phone must be filed within 48 hours; missed timing requires immediate return. Check the protocol, court record and asserted basis for retaining the device.

Published

28 August 2026

Legally reviewed

28 August 2026

Author

[Vitaliy Bessonov](https://bessonov.com.ua/en/about) Attorney-at-law, license No. 1893 dated 18 February 2015

## Quick action plan

1. Record the exact taking time; obtain the search warrant, protocol and inventory, and check the model, IMEI, SIM cards, screen state, packaging and written comments
2. Read the warrant’s operative part: determine whether the phone is identified precisely or generically and for what purpose; separately establish whether a restraint order exists
3. Check the court register and court office for the petition’s receipt date and time, subject and outcome; do not merge the 48-hour filing period, the two-day consideration period and the 72-hour order period
4. If the device remains temporarily seized without a timely petition or order, demand return under Article 169 and Article 171(5); if authorities remain inactive, consider an Article 303 complaint
5. If restraint has been imposed, test the order’s reasoning, Article 98 criteria, Article 170 purpose, proportionality and whether copying data could replace retention; prepare an Article 174 motion where supported

## What the law provides

Article 167 of Ukraine’s Criminal Procedure Code (CPC) defines temporary seizure as factual deprivation of the ability to possess, use and dispose of property pending a decision on a restraint order, return or special confiscation. It is a factual, transitional status: the phone has been taken, but taking it is not itself a judicial restraint order.

Under Article 170 CPC, restraint of property is a separate temporary restriction on transfer, disposal and/or use imposed by an investigating judge or court. It is available only for a statutory purpose: preserving physical evidence, special confiscation, confiscation as punishment, or securing a civil claim or recovery of unlawful benefit. When evidence preservation is asserted, the court considers whether the item meets Article 98, the legal basis, potential evidentiary use, proportionality and consequences. An investigator’s decision to classify a phone as physical evidence does not replace the judicial order.

Article 168(2) contains special rules for phones. Temporary seizure of a mobile terminal to examine its physical properties is permitted only where the device is expressly identified in the court order. As a rule, temporary seizure of electronic systems and mobile terminals is prohibited except in the listed situations: expert examination is necessary, the item resulted from or was used as a means or instrument of an offence, the holder restricts access, or logical protection must be overcome.

Article 236(7) describes items and documents outside the search warrant’s list, unless withdrawn from circulation, as temporarily seized property. The operative part of the warrant must therefore be read first: compare the precise or generic device description and the authorized purpose. Listing a phone in a search warrant does not turn that warrant into a restraint order. A separate order is needed for restraint, while application of temporary-seizure deadlines depends on the particular device’s procedural status.

Article 171(5) establishes two filing periods. The general rule is no later than the next working day after temporary seizure. Where property is temporarily seized during a search or inspection under an investigating judge’s order issued under Article 235, the petition must be filed within 48 hours after seizure; otherwise the property must be returned immediately.

Article 172 requires the petition to be considered no later than two days after it reaches the court. Article 173(6) separately requires an order concerning temporarily seized property no later than 72 hours after the petition reaches the court; otherwise the item must be returned. The triggering events differ: 48 hours runs from seizure to filing, while 72 hours runs from court receipt to the order.

Article 169 lists return grounds, including a prosecutor’s finding that seizure was unfounded, refusal of restraint, missed Articles 171 or 173 timing, cancellation of restraint and other express cases. Once restraint exists, Article 174 allows an owner, holder, suspect or defense counsel to seek full or partial cancellation by showing that the need has ended or the restraint was unjustified; the motion must be considered within three days of receipt.

Failure to return temporarily seized property may be challenged under Article 303(1)(1). In Decision No. 8-r(II)/2026 of 21 July 2026, the Second Senate of the Constitutional Court held unconstitutional the absence of appellate review where an investigating judge refuses such a non-return complaint. The relevant restrictions ceased to operate, in the aspect defined by the Decision, on that date. This concerns a complaint about non-return of temporarily seized property and does not automatically govern every Article 174 cancellation decision.

## What follows from case law

In its 27 March 2019 judgment in case No. 202/1452/18, proceeding No. 14-559цс18, the Supreme Court’s Grand Chamber considered an owner who was not a participant in the criminal proceeding. It held that where restraint was imposed under the 2012 CPC, the owner must use CPC remedies, including a cancellation motion, rather than a civil claim. That conclusion selects the proper jurisdiction; it does not decide whether restraint of a particular phone is justified.

In its 20 May 2024 judgment in case No. 712/191/23, proceeding No. 51-3208кмо23, the Joint Chamber of the Criminal Cassation Court distinguished the initial order imposing or refusing restraint from a later order deciding an Article 174 cancellation motion. It held that an order cancelling restraint or refusing cancellation is not separately appealable, while a refusal does not prevent a renewed motion. This must not be confused with Constitutional Court Decision No. 8-r(II)/2026 concerning refusal of a complaint about non-return of temporarily seized property.

In its 29 April 2026 judgment in case No. 357/9031/24, proceeding No. 51-234км26, the Third Chamber of the Criminal Cassation Court cancelled special confiscation of a phone. On the established facts, classification as physical evidence alone did not prove that the phone was used during or for the charged fraud, and the prosecutor had not supplied that proof. The judgment concerns special confiscation after trial; it does not automatically invalidate the initial taking or restraint of another device.

## Step-by-step action plan

Record the exact taking time; obtain the search warrant, protocol and inventory, and check the model, IMEI, SIM cards, screen state, packaging and written comments

Read the warrant’s operative part: determine whether the phone is identified precisely or generically and for what purpose; separately establish whether a restraint order exists

Check the court register and court office for the petition’s receipt date and time, subject and outcome; do not merge the 48-hour filing period, the two-day consideration period and the 72-hour order period

If the device remains temporarily seized without a timely petition or order, demand return under Article 169 and Article 171(5); if authorities remain inactive, consider an Article 303 complaint

If restraint has been imposed, test the order’s reasoning, Article 98 criteria, Article 170 purpose, proportionality and whether copying data could replace retention; prepare an Article 174 motion where supported

Preserve filing receipts, document copies, court orders and proof of service; for a renewed motion, identify new circumstances and why continued restriction is no longer necessary

## Common mistakes

Treating every taking as court-ordered restraint, or treating a search warrant as if it were already a restraint order

Applying 48 hours without establishing that the particular phone is temporarily seized and that the action occurred under an Article 235 order

Running the 72-hour period from the taking, although Article 173 uses court receipt of the petition

Relying only on an investigator’s physical-evidence decision without checking the separate judicial basis for retention

Seeking return without the protocol, inventory, search warrant and a verified timeline

Presenting one Supreme Court judgment as a universal guarantee of return, cancellation or exclusion of data

## Documents to give counsel

Provide every page of the search warrant, the protocol and attachments, inventory, available recording, restraint documents, physical-evidence decision, return correspondence, court receipts and your timeline. Where available, also provide documents about ownership, the need for the device for work, existing backups and the possibility of preserving the necessary data in a less burdensome way. The legal assessment depends not only on document labels but on exact timing, the operative wording and the factual purpose for retaining the phone.

❗ Publication and legal-review date: 28 August 2026\. Author: Vitaliy Bessonov, attorney; Ukrainian National Bar Association register profile: https://erau.unba.org.ua/profile/48623\. This article does not promise return, cancellation or any other outcome; the remedy depends on the documents and stage of the particular proceeding.

## Rule of law and case law

### What the law provides

- Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine — ст. 98, 167–174, 236, 303, 309

### What follows from case law

The Grand Chamber placed an owner’s remedy against a restraint imposed under the 2012 CPC within criminal procedure. In case No. 712/191/23, the Joint Chamber held that refusal to cancel a restraint under Article 174 is not separately appealable but does not prevent a renewed motion. That differs from refusal of a complaint about non-return of temporarily seized property, for which Constitutional Court Decision No. 8-r(II)/2026 confirmed a right of appeal.

## Official sources

- [Law Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine — ст. 98, 167–174, 236, 303, 309](https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/4651-17#Text)
- [Supreme Court Supreme Court Joint Chamber, 20 May 2024, case No. 712/191/23 — cancellation under Article 174 CPC](https://supreme.court.gov.ua/supreme/pres-centr/news/1623038/)
- [Supreme Court Constitutional Court Second Senate Decision No. 8-r(II)/2026 of 21 July 2026 — appeal concerning non-return of temporarily seized property](https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/v008p710-26)
- [Constitutional Court of Ukraine Official Constitutional Court notice on Decision No. 8-r(II)/2026](https://ccu.gov.ua/novyna/garantiyi-apelyaciynogo-oskarzhennya-dlya-zahystu-maynovyh-prav-na-stadiyi-dosudovogo)
- [Supreme Court Supreme Court Joint Chamber judgment of 20 May 2024 in case No. 712/191/23, proceeding No. 51-3208кмо23](https://reyestr.court.gov.ua/Review/119535382)
- [Supreme Court Supreme Court Grand Chamber, 27 March 2019, case No. 202/1452/18 — owner’s procedural remedy](https://supreme.court.gov.ua/supreme/pres-centr/news/712373/)
- [Supreme Court Supreme Court Grand Chamber judgment of 27 March 2019 in case No. 202/1452/18, proceeding No. 14-559цс18](https://reyestr.court.gov.ua/Review/81139238)
- [Supreme Court Supreme Court April 2026 review — phone in case No. 357/9031/24](https://strapi.supreme.court.gov.ua/uploads/Oglyad_KKS_04_2026_f6cd695a6c.pdf)
- [Supreme Court Supreme Court Third Chamber judgment of 29 April 2026 in case No. 357/9031/24, proceeding No. 51-234км26](https://reyestr.court.gov.ua/Review/136236988)
- [Registry Unified State Register of Court Decisions](https://reyestr.court.gov.ua/)
- [Registry Supreme Court Legal Positions Database](https://lpd.court.gov.ua/)
[Verify in the Ukrainian Bar Registry](https://erau.unba.org.ua/profile/48623)

## Frequently asked questions

How long is allowed for a phone-restraint petition after a search?

If the phone is temporarily seized during a search or inspection conducted under an investigating judge’s order, Article 171(5) requires the petition within 48 hours after seizure. For other temporary seizure, the same provision requires filing by the next working day. The device’s exact status must be established first.

Is a phone already restrained merely because the search warrant lists it?

No. A search warrant authorizes a search within defined limits, while Article 170 restraint is a separate judicial restriction of property rights. Article 236(7), however, links temporary-seizure status to whether the item was within the warrant list. Read the operative part and check for a separate restraint order.

How can a person check whether a phone has been restrained?

A separate order of an investigating judge or court must identify the property, basis, restriction and execution method. Compare the proceeding number, seizure date and time, petition receipt date and order date, and obtain a copy from the court or through counsel. An investigator’s physical-evidence resolution does not replace that order.

What if a temporarily seized phone is not returned without a restraint order?

Collect the protocol, inventory, search warrant and timeline. Articles 169 and 303 provide for return and a complaint about failure to return the item. Following Constitutional Court Decision No. 8-r(II)/2026, refusal of that complaint must be open to appellate review. The precise application depends on verifying the item’s status.

What can be done once the phone is already under a restraint order?

Under Article 174, an owner, holder, suspect or defense lawyer may seek full or partial cancellation by proving that the restraint was unjustified or is no longer needed. In case No. 712/191/23, the Joint Chamber held that refusal under Article 174 is not separately appealable but does not bar a renewed motion based on new or properly supported circumstances.

This material provides general information. Defense strategy depends on the circumstances of each case.

## Related articles

[Phone & Device Seizure: Know Your RightsWhen law enforcement can seize your smartphone, laptop, or server, and how to protect confidential data.](https://bessonov.com.ua/en/knowledge/phone-and-device-seizure) [Asset Seizure: How to Protect Your PropertyThe procedure for seizing bank accounts, real estate, and vehicles. How to challenge and recover seized property.](https://bessonov.com.ua/en/knowledge/property-arrest) [How to Describe a Seized Phone and Equipment in a Search ProtocolFor each device, ask the protocol and inventory to state its type, manufacturer, model, colour, serial number or IMEI, visible condition, attached SIM cards and media, discovery location, packaging method and package number. Record any data copying and how the copy was identified separately. Obtain the second protocol copy; completeness of the description does not automatically determine the case outcome.](https://bessonov.com.ua/en/knowledge/describe-seized-phone-in-search-protocol)

[Call the attorney](tel:+380979076262) [Message on Telegram](https://t.me/advokatbessonov_krim)
