BESSONOVCriminal Defense
Back to knowledge base
Procedures8 min

Building an appeal argument in Ukrainian criminal proceedings: facts, law and evidence

Published
Legally reviewed
Author
Vitaliy BessonovAttorney-at-law, license No. 1893 dated 18 February 2015

Step-by-step action plan

  1. Identify the finding or procedural action challenged and its location in the decision.
  2. Identify the supporting document, recording, testimony or hearing record, giving a volume, page or timestamp where possible.
  3. Explain the inconsistency or possible breach and connect it to the applicable rule.
  4. Explain why the point matters to the court's conclusion.
  5. Make a procedural request that follows from the argument and fits the appellate court's powers.

Start with the decision and the scope of appeal

Check the deadline and filing route immediately: waiting for the full text does not by itself postpone the start of the appeal period. Obtain the complete decision and establish who is entitled to appeal and which part affects that person's interests. Appealability of a verdict, a first-instance court ruling and an investigating judge's ruling must be checked separately. As a general rule, the appellate court reviews a decision within the scope of the appeal; the Code provides specific circumstances for going beyond it.

Article 396 of Ukraine's Criminal Procedure Code requires the appeal to identify the decision and court, the appellant's requests and reasons, any application to examine evidence and the list of attachments. Defence counsel must attach properly documented authority. Other requirements in that article, including signature and copies, apply subject to statutory exceptions.

Separate factual, evidential and legal issues

A factual argument identifies a specific finding that may not correspond to circumstances examined in the proceedings. Cite the relevant passage and material that calls it into question. For example, if a finding about the time of an event does not match a recording examined at trial, identify the recording, the relevant segment and how the court assessed it. This is a hypothetical illustration, not a conclusion about an actual case.

An evidence argument may concern the origin, admissibility, relevance, reliability or completeness of the assessment of evidence. Instead of making a general allegation about inadmissible evidence, identify the item, the relevant circumstances of its collection or examination, where those circumstances are recorded and their possible significance to the decision. A problem with one item does not automatically exclude all evidence.

A legal argument explains which rule the appellant considers misapplied or which procedural requirement may have been breached. Compare the rule with the facts found by the court and explain the significance of the possible breach. When citing a Supreme Court decision, identify its date, case number and relevant holding and compare the material facts. A decision in another case does not guarantee the same result.

This division helps organise an appeal. The statutory grounds for changing or setting aside a decision appear in Articles 409–414 of the Code; their application depends on the decision and the specific issue.

Build a chain the court can check

Identify the finding or procedural action challenged and its location in the decision.
Identify the supporting document, recording, testimony or hearing record, giving a volume, page or timestamp where possible.
Explain the inconsistency or possible breach and connect it to the applicable rule.
Explain why the point matters to the court's conclusion.
Make a procedural request that follows from the argument and fits the appellate court's powers.

Use a separate heading for each issue. This helps the court and other participants understand what must be checked.

When to request a renewed examination of evidence

Under Article 404(3), on an application by a participant in the proceedings, the appellate court must re-examine established circumstances if the first-instance court examined them incompletely or with violations. Evidence not examined at first instance may be examined by the appellate court only if participants requested its examination during proceedings in the first-instance court or if that evidence became known after the challenged decision.

Identify the specific circumstances and evidence and explain why examination is requested. Article 396(4) requires an appeal relying on circumstances not examined, or evidence not submitted, at first instance to explain why. Making an application does not itself determine the appeal's outcome.

What a Supreme Court decision illustrates

In its decision of 13 April 2021 in case No. 752/6631/18-к, proceeding No. 51-1999км20, a panel of judges of the Second Judicial Chamber of the Supreme Court's Criminal Cassation Court set aside an appellate ruling and ordered a new appellate hearing. According to the Supreme Court's account, the appellate court had dealt formally with specific defence arguments, including allegations of unlawful investigative methods and the right to defence. The decision concerns its own facts; it does not mean that every similar allegation automatically requires a decision to be set aside.

Common mistakes

Repeating disagreement without identifying the finding and relevant material.
Citing case law without comparing the relevant facts.
Asking for all evidence to be examined without explaining which circumstances were examined incompletely or with violations.
Combining requests to change or set aside a decision without checking the grounds and available remedies.
Overlooking the deadline, filing route, signatory's authority or attachments.

Legal basis

What the law provides

  • Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine — ст. 392–396, 403–404, 409–414, 419

Official sources

Verify in the Ukrainian Bar Registry

Frequently asked questions

Is it enough to say that the court assessed evidence incorrectly?

Identify the evidence, the alleged defect and its relevance to the decision. General disagreement does not explain what the appellate court should check.

Can new evidence be submitted?

Explain why it was not submitted at first instance. That explanation alone is insufficient: examination depends on the conditions in Article 404(3) concerning a request at first instance or the evidence becoming known after the challenged decision.

Can an appeal be amended?

Article 403 permits changes or additions before the appellate hearing begins and imposes a separate restriction on changes worsening an accused person's position outside the appeal period.

Does a Supreme Court citation guarantee success?

No. The current law, the holding and the comparability of the facts all matter.

This material provides general information. Defense strategy depends on the circumstances of each case.

Related articles

ВИКЛИКTGWATIKTOK