BESSONOVCriminal Defense
Back to knowledge base
Procedures5 min

Criminal appeals and reclassification in Ukraine’s Supreme Court in November 2026

Published
Legally reviewed
Author
Vitaliy BessonovAttorney-at-law, license No. 1893 dated 18 February 2015

Step-by-step action plan

  1. Identify the fact found in the judgment, the element of the offence and the Criminal Code provision the court applied.
  2. Identify the disputed point. State separately any error in fact-finding, assessment of evidence or application of the law.
  3. Compare the existing and proposed classifications. If a disputed circumstance needs to be re-examined, give reasons for a separate application under Article 404 CPC.
  4. Check any appeals by other participants and the relief they seek. State the decision sought within the appellate court’s powers.
  5. When citing a Supreme Court judgment, give its date and case number and explain which legally relevant facts correspond to those in your case.

What the appellate court can review

This review covers three judgments of the Criminal Cassation Court within the Supreme Court of Ukraine, dated 2, 5 and 12 November 2026. In each case, a party challenged the legal classification or the adequacy of the appellate court’s review of it.

Article 404(1) of the Criminal Procedure Code (CPC) limits review to the scope of the appeal. Under Article 404(2), the court may go beyond the relief sought if doing so does not make the defendant’s position worse. Article 404(4) confines the appellate hearing to charges brought at first instance.

Article 408(1)(2) provides for amendment of the judgment when the facts support an offence of lesser gravity. Under Article 420(1)(1), applying the law on a more serious offence requires the appellate court to set aside the judgment and deliver its own judgment. Under Article 421(1), the prosecutor, the victim or the victim’s representative must have appealed on the relevant grounds for that adverse change to be possible. The other legal requirements for the decision must also be satisfied.

If the appellate court dismisses the appeal, Article 419(2) requires it to give the reasons for finding the appeal unfounded. The review needed depends on the submissions and the case record.

Article 413(1)(1)–(2) CPC covers failure to apply the proper law and application of a provision that does not apply. A classification ground should identify the error in the choice of provision.

Three Criminal Cassation Court judgments

2 November, case No. 755/8937/21. Theft or fraud in an automated transaction

In proceeding No. 51-2852кмо25, the Joint Chamber considered the taking of another person’s property through automated transactions. To distinguish theft from fraud, it asked whether deception induced a person to hand over the property voluntarily. It classified the covert taking of property through an unauthorised automated transaction, in the absence of such influence, as theft under Article 185 of the Criminal Code.

The Joint Chamber set aside the Kyiv Court of Appeal’s ruling and ordered a new appellate hearing. The ruling had failed to address specific submissions about admissibility and the facts of the case. The appellate court was also required to revisit the legal classification at the new hearing.

In drafting an appeal, identify who disposed of the property and what brought about that decision. Relate those facts to the elements of the relevant offence. For any disputed item of evidence, explain which finding in the judgment relies on it.

5 November, case No. 712/5389/23. When the appellate court’s reasons stood up on cassation

In proceeding No. 51-775км26, the Second Judicial Chamber reviewed a case concerning acquisition of title to an apartment by deception and subsequent disposal of the property. On the facts established in the case, it upheld the classification under Article 190(3) and Article 209(1) of the Criminal Code.

The defence disputed, among other things, the elements of the offence, the classification and the admissibility of evidence. The Court found that the appellate court had given reasoned answers to the submissions and left both decisions in place.

When relying on Article 419 CPC, identify the specific submission, the page of the appeal, the relevant part of the ruling and why the submission mattered to the result. If the court gave reasons, explain the error in those reasons.

12 November, case No. 991/1196/24. A less serious offence and the opportunity to defend

In proceeding No. 51-4637км25, the Second Judicial Chamber reviewed a judgment in which the High Anti-Corruption Court classified the conduct under Article 369-2(2) of the Criminal Code, abuse of influence, in place of the completed attempt to incite the provision of an undue advantage. The defence challenged the scope of the charge and the opportunity to prepare a defence.

On the facts, the Court agreed that the first-instance court had applied the law on a less serious offence within the scope of the indictment read in court. It also found that the defence had the procedural opportunity to challenge that classification on appeal and had exercised it. The Court reduced the principal sentence and upheld the classification under Article 369-2(2).

If the trial court applied a different provision, compare the conduct described in the indictment with the findings in the judgment. Check which elements changed, how the new classification affected the defendant’s position and what opportunity the defence had to contest it in the proceedings.

How to draft the classification ground in an appeal

Identify the fact found in the judgment, the element of the offence and the Criminal Code provision the court applied.
Identify the disputed point. State separately any error in fact-finding, assessment of evidence or application of the law.
Compare the existing and proposed classifications. If a disputed circumstance needs to be re-examined, give reasons for a separate application under Article 404 CPC.
Check any appeals by other participants and the relief they seek. State the decision sought within the appellate court’s powers.
When citing a Supreme Court judgment, give its date and case number and explain which legally relevant facts correspond to those in your case.

Common mistakes when citing case law

Treating a party’s submission as a Supreme Court holding. Check the parties’ arguments, the court’s reasons and the operative part of the judgment.
Treating a new appellate hearing as a change in classification. In case No. 755/8937/21 the appellate court was to review the classification at its new hearing.
Assessing seriousness by the number or name of the offence alone. Compare the applicable versions of the law, their penalties and the procedural consequences for the defendant.

Legal basis

What the law provides

Article 337 CPC defines the scope of the first-instance hearing. Articles 404 and 419 govern the scope of appellate review and reasons for the ruling. Articles 408, 420 and 421 govern the form of decision and the conditions for an adverse change.

  • Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine — 337, 404, 408, 413, 419–421, 439
  • Criminal Code of Ukraine — 12, 15, 27, 185, 190, 209, 369, 369-2

Official sources

Verify in the Ukrainian Bar Registry

Frequently asked questions

How do I challenge the legal classification on appeal?

Identify the fact found by the court and the element of the offence that gives rise to the error. Explain which Criminal Code provision should apply, citing the case record, and state the relief sought within the appellate court’s powers.

Can an appellate court apply the law on a more serious offence?

Article 421(1) CPC requires an appeal on the relevant grounds from the prosecutor, the victim or the victim’s representative. If the court finds it necessary to apply a more serious provision within those limits, it delivers its own judgment under Article 420 CPC.

What should I check if the appellate court rejected a classification argument?

Compare the appeal with the reasons in the ruling. Article 419(2) CPC requires the court to explain why it dismissed the appeal. Identify the material submission that went unanswered or explain where the court’s reasons were wrong.

What happens if the appellate ruling is set aside and the case is sent back?

The appellate court hears the appeal again and must take account of the cassation court’s directions. In case No. 755/8937/21 the Joint Chamber directed it to review the defence submissions and the legal classification.

This material provides general information. Defense strategy depends on the circumstances of each case.

Related articles

ВИКЛИКTGWATIKTOK