New evidence on appeal: what the defence needs to explain
- Published
- Legally reviewed
- Author
- Vitaliy BessonovAttorney-at-law, license No. 1893 dated 18 February 2015
Step-by-step action plan
- Identify the specific document, recording, testimony or other material and the fact it may support or refute.
- Check whether it was submitted at first instance, whether its examination was requested and how the court decided the request; identify supporting material in the file.
- If the evidence became known after the decision, explain when and how; preserve available supporting records.
- If a circumstance was not examined or evidence was not submitted to the first-instance court, state the reasons in the appeal as required by Article 396 CPC.
- Specify what examination is requested, why it matters to the appeal and how the material's origin and admissibility can be checked.
What “new evidence” means in this context
In ordinary language, “new” may describe material previously unknown or material already in the case file but not examined by the court. For Article 404 of the Criminal Procedure Code (CPC), establish the procedural history of the particular evidence rather than relying on the label. Obtain the judgment, the hearing log and any available hearing recording, copies of the requests and the decisions on them.
Re-examination concerns circumstances already examined at first instance. At a participant's request, the appellate court must re-examine established circumstances if the first-instance court examined them incompletely or with violations. Explain precisely which circumstances and defects are involved; a general request to “check everything” may be insufficient.
When evidence not previously examined may be examined
Article 404(3) CPC permits examination of evidence not examined by the first-instance court exclusively in two alternative situations: participants requested examination of that evidence during the first-instance proceedings, or the evidence became known after the challenged decision was issued. This is a power available to the court when the statutory conditions are met, not an automatic duty to accept every item.
Under Article 396(4) CPC, an appeal referring to circumstances not examined at first instance or evidence not submitted to that court must state the reasons. That explanation alone does not replace the conditions in Article 404. The date a copy of a document was received does not necessarily coincide with when the evidence became known: explain and support the facts concerning awareness and any earlier request.
What to check and include in the request
What case law shows
In its decision of 3 April 2023 in case No. 537/984/20, proceeding No. 51-1747кмо22, the Joint Chamber of the Criminal Cassation Court addressed a specific situation: where an appeal by the prosecutor, victim or victim's representative requests a new judgment and argues that the court's findings do not correspond to the facts and/or that criminal law was incorrectly applied, the appellate court may re-examine established circumstances without a separate request. This conclusion about re-examination does not remove the conditions for examining evidence not examined at first instance.
In its decision of 5 May 2025 in case No. 206/4411/23, proceeding No. 51-4582км24, a panel of the Third Judicial Chamber of the Criminal Cassation Court reviewed a refusal to re-examine an audio recording: the appellate court considered the defence request, and persuasive grounds for re-examination had not been shown on the facts of that case. This does not mean every refusal is lawful.
Common mistakes
Legal basis
What the law provides
- Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine — ст. 84–86, 94, 396, 404
Official sources
- LawCriminal Procedure Code of Ukraine — ст. 84–86, 94, 396, 404
- Supreme CourtJoint Chamber, 3 April 2023, case No. 537/984/20
- Supreme CourtJoint Chamber, 3 April 2023, case No. 537/984/20
- Supreme CourtCriminal Cassation Court, 5 May 2025, case No. 206/4411/23
- RegistryUnified State Register of Court Decisions
- RegistrySupreme Court Legal Positions Database
Frequently asked questions
Can material not examined at first instance be submitted?
A party may attach the material and request its examination. Whether the court may examine it is governed by Article 404(3) CPC: an earlier request during the first-instance proceedings or the evidence becoming known after the decision matters.
Is it enough to say the evidence was obtained later?
No. Explain when it became known, how it was obtained and why it was not submitted earlier; Articles 396 and 404 CPC apply according to the facts.
Must the appellate court re-examine all evidence?
Not automatically. Article 404(3) CPC requires re-examination of established circumstances on request if their examination was incomplete or involved violations; applicable case law must also be considered.
Does examination mean the court will believe the evidence?
No. The court assesses each item's relevance, admissibility and reliability, as well as the body of evidence, under the CPC.